Search the Site

Top 20 Texas Family Law Cases: ARNOLD v. LEONARD

Top 20 Texas Family Law Cases Case 2: ARNOLD v. LEONARD.

This week we present the second case in our Top 20 Texas Family Law Cases series for San Antonio family law attorneys. ARNOLD v. LEONARD helped clarify separate property in Texas.

Understanding Separate Property in Texas Family Law

ARNOLD v. LEONARD, 273 S.W. 799 (Tex. 1925)

ARNOLD v. LEONARD Background

Adele Leonard owned certain separate property which she used as rental property. Adele’s husband had a judgment debt (derived during the marriage) against him which was owed to Guz Shultz who was deceased. The administrator of Shultz’s estate, Gus Arnold, tried to collect rents and revenues from Adele’s separate property assets to satisfy the debt. The trial court granted an injunction in favor of the Leonards and prevented Arnold from collecting Adele’s rents and revenues to satisfy the judgment debt.

The Court Decision

“Since rents and revenues derived from the wife’s separate lands are entirely without the constitutional definition of the wife’s separate property, and since the Legislature can neither enlarge nor diminish such property, it follows that the portions of the Acts of 1917 and 1921, which undertake to make rents and revenues from the wife’s separate lands a part of her separate estate, are invalid.”

Therefore, the rents and revenues collected from the wife’s separate property were community property, and the statutes were held unconstitutional.

Significance of Case

Although separate property is clearly defined in the Texas Constitution, in 1917 and 1921, the Texas Legislature had attempted to expand the definition with respect to separate property

“All property, both real and personal, of the wife, owned or claimed by her before marriage, and that acquired afterward by gift, devise or descent, shall be her separate property; and laws shall be passed more clearly defining the rights of the wife, in relation as well to her separate property as that held in common with her husband. Laws shall also be passed providing for the registration of the wife’s separate property.”
The Texas Constitution

The Arnold Court correctly points out that at no time has the Texas Constitution ever expanded the definition of separate property. However, the prior versions of the Constitution had allowed increases of land and slaves to be included in the definition of a woman’s separate property during coverture. It was likely this definition led to the Texas Legislature venturing into the rents and revenues definitions.

But the Supreme Court, citing previous precedent, determined that the rule of construction of constitutions is that “when the circumstances are specified under which any right is to be acquired there is an implied prohibition against legislative power to either add or withdraw from the circumstances specified.”

Top 20 Texas Family Law Cases: GLEICH v. BONGIO

Read case number 3, GLEICH v. BONGIO, helped clarify separate property in Texas family law.

 

Authors

Justin Morely | Family Law Attorney San Antonio

Justin Morley

Author
Justin Morley primarily practices family law at Langley & Banack’s San Antonio and New Braunfels locations. Mr. Morley’s family law experience includes divorce, child custody, visitation, complex property divisions, alimony, paternity issues, prenuptial agreements, and adoption cases. He is Board Certified in Family Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, and a frequent writer and speaker on family law topics. Scene S.A named Mr. Morley a Rising Star in 2011 and one of the Best S.A. Lawyers in 2015.

Kristal Thomson | Family Lawyer San Antonio

Kristal Thomson

Author
Kristal Thomson is a family law specialist, board certified in family law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization. She focuses on divorces with complex or high net worth estates and complicated custody issues. Her expertise is recognized state-wide through her numerous writing and speaking engagements and involvement in various family law related leadership positions. Ms. Thomson is one of only ten lawyers in San Antonio elected as a fellow to the prestigious American Academy of Matrimonial Specialists.

 

Find Your Lawyer

  • Family Law Lawyers
    Family & Divorce Attorneys Family matters are complicated situations that require expertise to run smoothly. If you are having difficulty with where to start our practice can help you start moving in the right direction. ...